Jump to content
I will no longer be developing resources for Invision Community Suite ×
By fans, for fans. By fans, for fans. By fans, for fans.

Ratings

LFCNeil90

By LFCNeil90
in Liverpool FC

 Share

Recommended Posts

LFCNeil90

LFCNeil90

Posted
Posted

Reina - 7

Kromkamp - 8 MOM

Carragher - 7

Hyypia - 7

Traore - 7

Kewell - 7

Hamman - 7

Gerrard - 8

Cisse - 7

Fowler - 6

Crouch 6

 

Riise - 7

Alonso - 7

Morientes didnt have time

Cisse

Cisse

Posted
Posted

Reina 7

Kromkamp 9, MOM

Carra 8

Sami 7

Djimi 7

Cisse 7.5

Stevie 8

Didi 6.5

Kewell 7

Fowler 5

Crouch 6.5

 

JAR 6

Xabi 7

 

We turn every goalie into Gordon Banks, so tedious

redjersey

redjersey

Posted
Posted

Reina - 7

Kromkamp - 7

Carragher - 8

Hyypia - 7

Traore - 4

Kewell - 9

Hamman - 7

Gerrard - 8

Cisse - 7

Fowler - 7

Crouch 7

 

Riise - 7

Alonso - 8

 

Kromkamp was my MOM but I don't think he was worth more than a 7. 6 for the rest. A very average performance.

ajit

ajit

Posted
Posted

Reina 7

 

Kromkamp 8 - could give finnan a run for his money

Carragher 7

Hyypiä 7

Traore 5 -just cos he keeps scaring the crap out of me

 

Kewell 7

Hamann 6

Gerrard 7

Cissé 7

 

Fowler 6

Crouch 6

 

Riise 7

Alonso 7

Frosty Jack

Frosty Jack

Posted
Posted

Lack of finishing and general s***tery.

 

Lack of finishing? he was on target a couple of times, and his crossing was generally good, got the better of his marker as the game went on, and created chances, what exactly was he supposed to do?

 

he's getting blamed for the offside, from what i saw, his upper body was marginally, but his feet were on the line, and according to the rule, he wasn't interfering with play anyway.

 

I said the same thing last time he was played on the wing, if we had signed Victor in January and he put in that performance, the analysis would be completely different on here.

Guest chiael

Guest chiael

Posted
Posted

Reina 7

Kromkamp 8

Carragher 8

Hyypia 7

Traore 7

Cisse 7

Hamann 6.5

Gerrard 8

Kewell 8.5

Fowler 7

Crouch 6.5

 

Riise 7

Alonso 7.5

 

 

As long as it's Traore, it's going to be a poor performance. Did he score an own goal , gave the ball away in the penalty area or made Reina the star or was I watching a different game ?

 

I'm not saying he did great. But a 4 is really under the belt.

 

Gez :angry:

Nerik

Nerik

Posted
Posted

Reina 6.5

Kromkamp 7

Carra 7

Sami 6.5

Traore 6

Kewell 6.5

Didi 6.5

Gerrard 6.5

Cisse 6.5

Fowler 6

Crouch 6

 

Subs

 

Riise 6

Nando 6

Alonso 6.5

_00_deathscar

_00_deathscar

Posted
Posted

Lack of finishing? he was on target a couple of times, and his crossing was generally good, got the better of his marker as the game went on, and created chances, what exactly was he supposed to do?

 

he's getting blamed for the offside, from what i saw, his upper body was marginally, but his feet were on the line, and according to the rule, he wasn't interfering with play anyway.

 

I said the same thing last time he was played on the wing, if we had signed Victor in January and he put in that performance, the analysis would be completely different on here.

 

I'm not denying he had a decent game - but it was a decent game by HIS standards. He also fluffed about 3 or 4 crosses, and failed to beat the full back quite a few times in trying to trick him and f*** up when Kromkamp or Gerrard were behind him, wide open. Not sure if anyone else noticed that.

 

Having said that, I gave him a 7.

 

As long as it's Traore, it's going to be a poor performance. Did he score an own goal , gave the ball away in the penalty area or made Reina the star or was I watching a different game ?

 

I'm not saying he did great. But a 4 is really under the belt.

 

Gez :angry:

 

I didn't give him a 4 though.... :wacko:

 

I suppose you were quoting the wrong person or referring to my response about where the ratings for Traore below 6 are coming from.

jariiiiiiiiiise

jariiiiiiiiiise

Posted
Posted

Where are all these ratings for Traore lower than 6 coming from?

 

was out mustled twice and fell over under no pressure which could have lead to chalton scoring wayward passing forward

thats why I gave him a 4

anny road

anny road

Posted
Posted

was out mustled twice and fell over under no pressure which could have lead to chalton scoring wayward passing forward

thats why I gave him a 4

 

 

and your totally wrong

 

Traore played ok yesterday

 

but gets low marks because of who is he is

 

Reina 6

Kromkamp 8

Hyypia 6

Carragher 7

Traore 6

Cisse 6

Gerrard 6

Hamann 6

Kewell 5

Fowler 6

Crouch 6

 

 

Riise 6

Alonso 7

Skillz

Skillz

Posted
Posted

and your totally wrong

 

Traore played ok yesterday

 

but gets low marks because of who is he is

Reina 6

Kromkamp 8

Hyypia 6

Carragher 7

Traore 6

Cisse 6

Gerrard 6

Hamann 6

Kewell 5

Fowler 6

Crouch 6

Riise 6

Alonso 7

 

Surely the same applies here.

 

Harry was in no way a 5 and to rate him as low as that shows you have biased view of his expected performance. What he have to do to get a 6, dominate and score matchwinning goals!

anny road

anny road

Posted
Posted

Surely the same applies here.

 

Harry was in no way a 5 and to rate him as low as that shows you have biased view of his expected performance. What he have to do to get a 6, dominate and score matchwinning goals!

 

 

no I thought Kewell didnt play well at all.....I might be wrong, and I havnt seen the game on TV again

 

I thought he was less of a threat than Cisse....

 

And I am Kewell fan

 

The reason why I put that about Traore was because he played in back four that gave nothing away....he played at Left back and Centre half and did well enough

Skillz

Skillz

Posted
Posted

no I thought Kewell didnt play well at all.....I might be wrong, and I havnt seen the game on TV again

 

I thought he was less of a threat than Cisse....

 

And I am Kewell fan

 

The reason why I put that about Traore was because he played in back four that gave nothing away....he played at Left back and Centre half and did well enough

 

I agree about Traore, thought he looked solid enough at centre half, having said that Charlton had little going forward all night. I watched it twice now (both on TV) thought Harry was very good. I am a fan and am probably biased myself but i would of given him a 7. He had 5 shots on target, 2 off, great interception at the death was important. Went a little quiet for period of the second half when we utilised Cisse a lot due to his getting the better of Spector (looked ok himself and had a good battle with Cisse).

 

Just thought 5 was very harsh.

surf

surf

Posted
Posted

I thought Kewell had a very good game, a lot of the things we created came from him. He looked our likeliest player to score, or provide a goal from a decent cross.

tag

tag

Posted
Posted

Reina - 7

Kromkamp - 8

Carragher - 7

Hyypia - 7

Traore - 6

Kewell - 7

Hamman - 5

Gerrard - 7

Cisse - 5

Fowler -6

Crouch 6

Riise - 6

Alonso -7

 

 

Cisse at 5? Admittedly he was a bit frustating, but i thought he was our best goal-threat.

 

Krompkamp my MOM as well.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.

Home

Notifications

PMs
×
×
  • Create New...