Transfer Window

[Guest Kev]

Got to say I've not been impressed on the whole of our transfer dealings in the last two transfer windows.

 

Reina was the obvious plus, but not much else for me.

 

What about the rest of you ?

[Rushian]

didn't you post this last week?

[CarraLegend]

  Rushian said:

didn't you post this last week?

 

Probably.

[Stevie H]

very pleased with reina, sissoko, crouch, zenden, kromkamp and agger.

 

tbc on fowler.

[Superjay]

To be fair i was just chuffed to come through the last window without and gerrard spec.

 

Happy enough....not fantastic but good enough for the time being.

[vish]

I'm happy with reina, sissoko, zenden, kromkamp & fowler

 

not too sure crouch is good enough for our ambitions.

 

unhappy we haven't got any kind of right midfielder, which has led to playing players out of position.

[4411]

  Kev said:

Got to say I've not been impressed on the whole of our transfer dealings in the last two transfer windows.

 

Reina was the obvious plus, but not much else for me.

 

What about the rest of you ?

 

Very disapointed that he didnt bring in a winger and Michael Owen.

 

This summer will tell us alot about Rafa and whether Liverpool will be challenging Chelsea or not. I just hope he doesnt do a Houllier and buys 2 or 3 expensive players from some african country just because they had a good world cup.

[IgPig]

I think of all the players we've bought in the last 2 have improved the squad and were needed.

[McBain]

Reina - Very pleased

 

Sissoko - Started off happy but he hasn't played well all year

 

Zenden - Not enough time to assess but for a free you cant argue

 

Crouch - Was desperate for us not to sign him and everything i've seen since he joined has confirmed what I feared

 

Agger - No way of knowing

 

Kromkamp - See above

 

Fowler - Delighted more for him than the club. My gut feeling is he wont be here next season

[Kvarme Ate My Food]

  Mcbain said:

Crouch - Was desperate for us not to sign him and everything i've seen since he joined has confirmed what I feared

 

everything?

 

he has had some superb games

[Stevie H]

  Kvarme Ate My Food said:

everything?

 

he has had some superb games

 

absolutely. there've been plenty of games where he's been almost unplayable. we just need to play off him and use him right.

[McBain]

  Kvarme Ate My Food said:

everything?

 

he has had some superb games

 

Everything overall yes. He's had some good games and I hope he has plenty more. But I still think he's very average

[Kvarme Ate My Food]

  Mcbain said:

Everything overall yes. He's had some good games and I hope he has plenty more. But I still think he's very average

 

fair play, it's a game of opinions and all that, but I actually can't believe that your view of him could differ so wildly from mine

[Tones]

  Stevie H said:

very pleased with reina, sissoko, crouch, zenden, kromkamp and agger.

 

tbc on fowler.

 

Pretty happy with those too. Delighted to see Robbie back too, remians to be seen whether its a good move or not. Certainly not a bad move.

 

The last 3 transfer windows have all been pretty decent apart from Owen leaving. Certainly better than the few transfer windows before those.

Edited February 9, 2006 by t1971

[Eiler99]

Very happy with Reina, Sissoko, Fowler and Agger.

 

Crouch looks to be a decent signing. Still not decided on Kromkamp and Zenden.

[Earl Hafler]

  Mcbain said:

Everything overall yes. He's had some good games and I hope he has plenty more. But I still think he's very average

 

So how did those good games confirm your worst fears about him ?

[McBain]

  Big Stuff said:

So how did those good games confirm your worst fears about him ?

 

I dont make opinions about players based on a handful of games

[Stevie H]

  Eiler99 said:

Still not decided on Kromkamp and Zenden.

 

one was free, one was swapped for josemi. what's not to like?

[matty]

Time to judge the transfer window is at the end of the season.

 

As Mao Tse Tung might have said "it's far too early to tell."

[Morgul]

  Mcbain said:

Reina - Very pleased

 

Sissoko - Started off happy but he hasn't played well all year

 

Zenden - Not enough time to assess but for a free you cant argue

 

Crouch - Was desperate for us not to sign him and everything i've seen since he joined has confirmed what I feared

 

Agger - No way of knowing

 

Kromkamp - See above

 

Fowler - Delighted more for him than the club. My gut feeling is he wont be here next season

 

Pretty much agree with you there, even though I think Crouch has had a few good games. But overall he hasn't surprised me, I felt the same as you before we signed him..

[Suth]

  Mcbain said:

Reina - Very pleased

 

Sissoko - Started off happy but he hasn't played well all year

 

Zenden - Not enough time to assess but for a free you cant argue

 

Crouch - Was desperate for us not to sign him and everything i've seen since he joined has confirmed what I feared

 

Agger - No way of knowing

 

Kromkamp - See above

 

Fowler - Delighted more for him than the club. My gut feeling is he wont be here next season

 

spot on, i agree with all that. there is no way of knowing about the new signings but on first impressions, Agger looks a better prospect than the Kromkamp.

[Kvarme Ate My Food]

b******s to this

[realtarragona]

Reina - Fine

 

Agger, Kromkamp - Dunno yet. Pleased Agger is meant to be a 'ball playing defender' for what it's worth.

 

Zenden - Ok for a free. Won't be arsed if he leaves in the summer.

 

Crouch - Good player on his day but needs a goalscorer (or at least more support) up there along with him.

 

Sissoko - Good signing, plenty of potential but right now can be frustrating

 

Fowler - Was made up but dunno yet whether that was based solely on sentimental reasons

Edited February 9, 2006 by realtarragona

[Guest ziggystardust]

i think crouch has played well up to jan, just seems to be fading slightly.

[Earl Hafler]

  Mcbain said:

I dont make opinions about players based on a handful of games

 

Not saying you do, just that you said everything you've seen has confirmed your fears about the transfer - he had an excellent run before Christmas.

 

I think he's a good signing. Wasn't a world beater in the autumn and he's not the worst player in the country now.