Carragher

[Murphman]

I can't f*cking stand him, his behaviour with that gobby Manc with his daughter in the car notwithstanding his commentary is dreadful and on Sunday I saw the depth of his jealousy and clear resentment at the success of this side we have now. Condemning Joe Gomez with real zeal, criticising the high line with step ups to catch opponents offside despite the very same system with the very same players having brought the glory days back at a level Carragher never saw.

 

Sunday was an abomination and one of those dreadful days where everything than can go wrong goes wrong, the record clearly shows this, Carragher had a ball, really enjoyed slagging the players off and more revealingly slagging Jurgen's 'system' off. he can f*ck off.

[PaulMcC186]

He's celebrated Liverpool win every trophy under Klopp. Doesn't look like he's anything other than happy when we win. He was out on the streets when Liverpool won the league, and it wasn't for publicity.

Edited October 6, 2020 by PaulMcC186

[Ant]

Murph - I was laughing my head off at 5-2 to be honest. He's sound 

[Leo No.8]

I’ve always thought he’s sound but f*cking hell he grated on me on Sunday!

Edited October 6, 2020 by Leo No.8

[D.Boon]

His Scouse tones annoy me.

Before people have a go some of my best friends have Scouse accents.

[Murphman]

1 hour ago, Ant said:

Murph - I was laughing my head off at 5-2 to be honest. He's sound 

What were you laughing at?

[Begbie]

Very harsh, not sure how you can reconcile seeing the joybour title brought him and hating him for reactionary comments in a bizarre and frustrating game.

Agree with those on here that don't rate him as a commentator,  talks too much. Otherwise he's one of us

[Barnesy_10]

He just doesn't shut up... 

Tries too hard to sound non biased but goes too far the opposite way and comes across sounding stupid... 

I think he's only really good when he's had time to prep what he's saying like he does on Monday Night Football... But during commentary with spontaneity he talks some s***e 

[Tommok]

15 minutes ago, Barnesy_10 said:

He just doesn't shut up... 

Tries too hard to sound non biased but goes too far the opposite way and comes across sounding stupid... 

I think he's only really good when he's had time to prep what he's saying like he does on Monday Night Football... But during commentary with spontaneity he talks some s***e 

Yeah he simply talks too much in commentary.

The best commentators make short punchy comments occasionally whilst the other one very briefly describes the action.

Carra goes off on long diatribes which might be OK in an analysis show but don't work in live game commentary and just get annoying and intrusive.

Sometimes he is speaking for so long, whilst trying to focus on the game, I think he gets distracted and actually forgets what point he's trying to make.

[Benzo-13]

He’s a pain in the hole commentating but decent at the analysis.

Also goes to extreme to try be neutral in his views. He’s better off being slanted as it doesn’t hurt Neville.

[Gethin]

Good analyst, s***e co-commentator. This isn't news.

[Kvarme Ate My Food]

1 hour ago, D.Boon said:

His Scouse tones annoy me.

Before people have a go some of my best friends have Scouse accents.

That’s s***, regardless of who your friends are.

[Jarg Armani]

1 hour ago, Begbie said:

Very harsh, not sure how you can reconcile seeing the joybour title brought him and hating him for reactionary comments in a bizarre and frustrating game.

Agree with those on here that don't rate him as a commentator,  talks too much. Otherwise he's one of us

This is about the size of it

[Swipe]

Another one for the 'reactionary' list.

[Hassony]

As everyone else said, he's an annoying commentator, good pundit usually

 

Never really liked him since his xenophobic comments when Hodgson (+Cole and Konchesky) joined the club 

3 hours ago, Ant said:

Murph - I was laughing my head off at 5-2 to be honest. He's sound 

Bizarre

[psl]

3 hours ago, Ant said:

Murph - I was laughing my head off at 5-2 to be honest. He's sound 

I mean, I'm not sure it was hilarious.

More absolutely f***ing s***e.

[D.Boon]

1 hour ago, Kvarme Ate My Food said:

That’s s***, regardless of who your friends are.

 

1 hour ago, Kvarme Ate My Food said:

That’s s***, regardless of who your friends are.

Wasn't being serious about the accent. His voice does annoy me though.

[Leo No.8]

I didn’t find Sunday funny.

Not one little bit.

[Hassony]

I still wake up every morning hoping that it's a very long dream

[jimmylibel]

I think he goes out of his way to criticise us during games. Constantly painting things bleakly. He’s overly negative about some aspect of our performance practically every match. 
 

[Ant]

17 hours ago, Murphman said:

What were you laughing at?

When it went 5-2 it was ridiculous 

The fact that he's not affiliating himself with Liverpool fans during commentary is probably means he's doing a good job.

I prefer his analysis during MNF than his commentary but there aren't many good commentators never mind co-commentators around other than Peter Drury probably. I like Neville on co-commentary 

[Cobs]

38 minutes ago, Ant said:

I like Neville on co-commentary 

he's f***ing dreadful

[scoose]

14 hours ago, Leo No.8 said:

I didn’t find Sunday funny.

Not one little bit.

Watching the crossbar incident again the day after I had to laugh. At the time I f***ing well didnt though

[Earl Hafler]

They both are. 

Imagine being a fan of the opposition when Neville is commentating on Utd games. Spurs beat them 6-1 and Neville is obsessed with the Utd aspect 

[Cobs]

Just now, Earl Hafler said:

They both are. 

Imagine being a fan of the opposition when Neville is commentating on Utd games. Spurs beat them 6-1 and Neville is obsessed with the Utd aspect 

totally

why Sky let him do Utd and Carra Lfc games is beyond me.