Ref watch 19/20

[Hassony]

Thought Oliver was ok on Friday, not a difficult match to ref though tbf

 

7/10

[Cheesecake]

Don’t think there was anything contentious in the game, was an easy one for him

Edited August 10, 2019 by DPD1973

[Hassony]

  On 10/08/2019 at 17:02, DPD1973 said:

Don’t think there was anything contentious in the game, was an easy one for him

 

True, some refs though would have made it more about themselves especially seeing how VAR was making its premiership debut

[Leo No.8]

Oliver is very good but agree, easy game for him.

 

Wonder if stats will be compiled about how many times refs get over ruled by VAR. I guess they will.

[Drexl]

Ref was good tonight.

[Gunga Din]

  On 14/08/2019 at 21:52, Drexl said:

Ref was good tonight.

 

 

yet got the single biggest decision wrong?

 

It was an easy game to ref, but towards the end  she got far too whistle happy. 

[Cobs]

  On 14/08/2019 at 22:40, Gunga Din said:

yet got the single biggest decision wrong?

 

It was an easy game to ref, but towards the end  she got far too whistle happy.

 

Biggest two decisions wrong - Their pen & our pen. Trent's booking was bobbins too.

[Cheesecake]

To be fair, if the VAR people were worth their salt they would have helped her with the two penalties, not her fault she was hung out to dry by them.

[Cobs]

  On 14/08/2019 at 23:17, DPD1973 said:

To be fair, if the VAR people were worth their salt they would have helped her with the two penalties, not her fault she was hung out to dry by them.

I think If she'd given our pen and not allowed theirs VAR would have backed her on that too

[Maldini]

They've really made an absolute dogs dinner of VAR, there were 3 or 4 major issues on Saturday as well. It needs to be the referee calling for assistance rather than an always on option. It's going to fundamentally change the game. The cynical part of me wonders how long until it's sponsored and we have picture in picture ads while we wait on the decision.

[Hassony]

  On 14/08/2019 at 23:25, Cobs said:

I think If she'd given our pen and not allowed theirs VAR would have backed her on that too

Isn't VAR there to help her? Especially on the first one

[Cheesecake]

if that Man U pen against PSG is given (and it shouldn't but was) then tonights one is a penalty all day long. Still a pen though making the body bigger etc.

[cocknose]

UEFA didn't want var to overrule her because of different reasons joe Cole said, and he was right.

 

Basic stuff like throws and goal kicks even went the wrong way.

[Martian]

Atrocious refereeing. This experiment should not be repeated.

[Cheesecake]

I may be wrong but if the ref says pen, can't VAR say NO?

I know that like in the PSG-MU game VAR overruled the ref and said pen, surely VAR can say hey ref - NO, you got it wrong?

[cocknose]

  On 15/08/2019 at 01:56, DPD1973 said:

I may be wrong but if the ref says pen, can't VAR say NO?

I know that like in the PSG-MU game VAR overruled the ref and said pen, surely VAR can say hey ref - NO, you got it wrong?

not on a night like this where they made such a big deal of her Reffing it. Edited August 15, 2019 by cocknose

[Cheesecake]

doesn't that make a balls of the whole thing though cocknose?

[downunder]

  On 10/08/2019 at 19:16, Leo No.8 said:

Oliver is very good but agree, easy game for him.

 

Wonder if stats will be compiled about how many times refs get over ruled by VAR. I guess they will.

 

Most decisions will be linesmen over-rules for offside won't they? So not just the refs.

[cocknose]

  On 15/08/2019 at 02:02, DPD1973 said:

doesn't that make a balls of the whole thing though cocknose?

Abso-f***ing-lutely

[New York Red]

Great that women are officiating. Absolutely no reason not to.

[McBain]

  On 15/08/2019 at 01:48, Martian said:

Atrocious refereeing. This experiment should not be repeated.

You're of the opinion her performance was based on her gender?

[cocknose]

  On 15/08/2019 at 04:57, New York Red said:

Great that women are officiating. Absolutely no reason not to.

I dont care if a goat refs it, just get things right and treat them the same as male refs, if she made a mistake yesterday then var should have stepped in but it didnt, twice because they didnt want to on this big occasion they had created by going on about the first female ref blah blah blah.

 

I thought she was poor, hardly blew her whistle, missed obvious things like throws and goal kicks going to the wrong team and got 2 penalties wrong

[Hassony]

  On 15/08/2019 at 04:57, New York Red said:

Great that women are officiating. Absolutely no reason not to.

True, but what was the biggest game that she has reffed prior to last night?

 

The refs at the women's world club were really bad overall

[cocknose]

ALL media outlets bending over backwards to say how good she was, its positive discrimination.

[muleskinner]

Seen better performances, definitely seen much much worse.