PFA Player if the Year

[Swipe]

Bale has won it. Laughable really.

 

Wilshere won young player.

[Earl Hafler]

Bale has won it. Laughable really.

 

Wilshere won young player.

 

 

Are you serious ?!

[dorgie]

Bale has won it. Laughable really.

 

It really is. Has he played even 4 decent games in the PL ? There were probably more consistent performers in the Spurs team, not to mention elsewhere in the league.

[Sion]

Blatently got it for a few decent goals and runs in the CL.

Because in the PL

 

P26, G7, A1

[muleskinner]

f***ing ridiculous.

[Cam]

Bale had one stunning game and a couple of good weeks either side of it.

 

Tevez & Nasri would both have been better choices but even they've been useless for the last couple of months.

[Swipe]

Rivals Giggs' win a few years back for ridiculous-ness!

Edited April 17, 2011 by Swipe

[Benzo-13]

Absolute rubbish decision.

They've got to change the voting time.

[Swipe]

AND... he came SECOND in young player awards!!

 

How the f*** does that work??!!

[muleskinner]

Play well up to early October and you are in with a shout.

[épieur]

should have been one of Tevez, Nasri or Nani. And jacko wasn't even nominated.

 

The biggest joke of an award given in many a year.

 

 

[dorgie]

Aurelio will feel hard done by on the basis of the apparant criteria that got Bale the award.

[Hassony]

he's not even been the best player at spurs this season

[Ombudsam]

AND... he came SECOND in young player awards!!

 

How the f*** does that work??!!

 

That's the one which is silly. how can you be the best player overall and the second best young player. either wishere should have been in for the main 6 or bale should have won both

[Sir Tokyo Sexwale]

not much I can add here - has he even played well since Christmas?

 

Was VDV 2nd?

 

I reckon that big lumbering idiot - Zlatan (drunk, couldn't remember his name, googled 'lumbering idiot barca milan' 1st return was Zlatan...

 

anyway did he get 3rd even though he hasn't played in England

[Rimbeux]

Absolute rubbish decision.

They've got to change the voting time.

They have, pulled the votes in a fortnight or so ago and still pro footballers demonstrate a tabloid thin grasp of what is actually going on.

[Cobs]

Mick Quinn said on the radio yesterday that the award means nothing, most players give the voting papers to some apprentice to fill in

[Benzo-13]

They have, pulled the votes in a fortnight or so ago and still pro footballers demonstrate a tabloid thin grasp of what is actually going on.

Ah FFS.

Be done with them so.

[Maldini]

We have this thread every year, they're always a farce. They're voted for in January.

[_00_deathscar]

]

I reckon that big lumbering idiot - Zlatan (drunk, couldn't remember his name, googled 'lumbering idiot barca milan' 1st return was Zlatan...

 

 

 

I tried this. Brilliant.

 

 

[Minder78]

Parker and Adam were shortlisted for POTY but were not in the team of the year.........

[jimmylibel]

And Reina yet again misses out on the 'Van der Saar' position in Team of the Year.

[Rimbeux]

And Reina yet again misses out on the 'Van der Saar' position in Team of the Year.

 

 

It's not been his best year, but there hasn't been an outstanding keeper and these are footballers voting

[jimmylibel]

It's not been his best year, but there hasn't been an outstanding keeper and these are footballers voting

 

Agreed. But that position in the team seems to be mostly based on the hype around the keeper and I don't think even Van der Saar has come close to the amount of kudos Pepe has been getting from Sky since August.