Worst footballer in the Premier League?

[Maldini]

My vote goes to Mamady Sidibe, his miss just now was classic. Never seen him do anything except be big.

[Zoob]

My vote goes to Mamady Sidibe, his miss just now was classic. Never seen him do anything except be big.

 

He's pretty good at being big though - you can't take that away from him.

 

I think Fuller's miss (at 1-1) was worse. Sidibe slipped over, was a bit unlucky. Fuller's miss was just horrible - one of those where it's easier to score than to sky it as he did.

[Nerik]

Tony Hibbert should surely be mentioned.

[Swipe]

Bendtner is up there for me. Well, in terms of "s**** players at big clubs".

 

Awful player, IMO.

[Nerik]

Bendtner does have the occasional good game in which one can see a glimpse of potential.

[Superjay]

Erm the answer is Michael Brown. No footballing ability at all, just a complete s***house.

[Maldini]

Bendtner? Hibbert? They're relatively s*** but they're not proper s***. Sidibe's like a rugby second-row trying to play football.

[doug_mac]

paul mcshane has to be up there hes muck

[carrafan]

No calls for Lucas yet?

[Nerik]

That striker Wigan bring on in every game and who barely touches a ball..........aargh forget his name.

 

Scotland!

[Cunny]

Keith Andrews at Blackburn.

He's surely a Jim'll Fix It winner.

[Logic]

Hermann Hreiðarsson should get an honourable mention in this list. When Pompey are relegated he will have played for 5 teams IIRC that have been relegated from the Premiership. Which is a record I think.

[deacon]

Hibbert's a good shout. Truly s***. But the worst is Dawson for Hull. Just looks way out of his depth.

 

Now I know he's not rubbish, but if we're talking about overrated players, Ballack's got to be top of the list. Whenever I watch Chelsea, I barely notice him on the pitch, he just does nothing. So ineffectual.

[CarraLegend]

paul mcshane has to be up there hes muck

 

Theres the winner. He is hopeless.

[Sion]

Paul McShane is truly awful. As are most of Hull's players. Fagan, Zayatte, Folan

Keith Andrews is really bad as well

[Maldini]

McShane is awful, but I've seen him have some amazing games when the game suits him and the whole game is head tennis and tackles. Sidibe is way worse.

[Ste M]

I ended up on Turf Moor the other Wednesday watching Burnley v Stoke - Sidibe is the correct answer.

 

I don't think he'd get a game in the Conference.

[Eiler99]

Michael Owen.

[Sion]

Michael Owen.

 

I think they have to play in the PL to get mentioned.

[Foo]

Erm the answer is Michael Brown. No footballing ability at all, just a complete s***house.

 

I considered posting him, so I will agree with you. Odious, horrible, plain s**** footballer. In every way. I cannot stand him.

[Hightown Phil]

On McShane, the other year we played Sunderland. They had a back four of Greg Halford, Paul McShane, Nyron Nosworthy and Ross Wallace.

 

We only scored two.

 

How?

[Benzo-13]

McShane is probably the winner but for me Micah Richards gets an honourable mention for having the positional sense of a one legged, one eared drunk against Giggs this season.

Made him look like Pelé in every game!!

Edited March 21, 2010 by Benzo-13

[New York Red]

Even though he isn't playing any more, Carlton Palmer is still the worst player in the Prem.

[Stevie H]

i'd have daniel cousin up there. never looked like a footballer, just a clumsy, lumbering f*ck.

[fyds]

Robert Huth merits a mention, as does Liam Ridgewell.