Adam Hamill

[Guest kring]

Going to Dunfermline according to Bascombe.

 

Is it a step in the right direction or has his bad discipline finally come back to haunt him??

Edited January 17, 2007 by kring

[IgPig]

Going to Dunfermline according to Bascombe.

 

Is it a step in the right direction or has his bad discipline finally come back to haunt him??

 

 

Gotta be a good thing.

 

Players of his ilk need to play.

[Sion]

Although Dunfermline are a poor side, bottom of SPL by a long distance.

[Zoob]

Would much prefer him to play for a champtionshp side, but I guess as long as he plays, the SPL is better than a reserve game every couple weeks.

[Maldini]

I don't think he's indisciplined. He's not really a troublemaker. He makes bad decisions on the pitch, that's it, he's a huge talent, could go either way though, a spell of regular football will help. Good manager too.

[Guest kring]

I hope Hamill get regular football up there. If so and if Rafa believes in him I think he could go on to be a fantastic player for us

[kozma]

If he can't get a game for Dunfermline, he'd better start looking for a more suitable job.

[Maldini]

Dunfermline have been s**** up to now, but Kenny is bringing in a few decent players. He's signed a couple of other wingers, James O'Brien from Celtic who is very highly rated and Bobby Ryan from Shelbourne who is a good player too so Hamill will have to prove himself to get into the team.

[Maldini]

Dunfermline - Rangers is on Setanta on Sunday so Irish Reds will be able to watch him if they have it.

[magneto]

I dunno bout this one. Loaning a player is common nowadays but it also smells like a "you're not gonna be good enough" type thing.

 

Gerrard, Owen, Carragher, Fowler never went on loan.

 

yet..

 

Warnock, Potter, Mellor, etc did

 

Can anyone name a player we've sent out on loan to return as a regular first teamer? Perhaps in the 80s or 90s?

[DJM]

If he can't get a game for Dunfermline, he'd better start looking for a more suitable job.

 

I think most of us could get a game for Dunfermline at the moment

[trowie]

I dunno bout this one. Loaning a player is common nowadays but it also smells like a "you're not gonna be good enough" type thing.

 

Gerrard, Owen, Carragher, Fowler never went on loan.

 

yet..

 

Warnock, Potter, Mellor, etc did

 

Can anyone name a player we've sent out on loan to return as a regular first teamer? Perhaps in the 80s or 90s?

Danny Murphy

[Boca]

I dunno bout this one. Loaning a player is common nowadays but it also smells like a "you're not gonna be good enough" type thing.

 

Gerrard, Owen, Carragher, Fowler never went on loan.

 

yet..

 

Warnock, Potter, Mellor, etc did

 

Can anyone name a player we've sent out on loan to return as a regular first teamer? Perhaps in the 80s or 90s?

 

Danny Murphy went back to Crewe for a bit I think.

[Ronnie Whelan]

Didnt Rushie go to Italy on loan?

[denver]

Good move, I think. I'd read some people thought he needed to toughen up a bit, and the SPL should help him there. And, as has been said, if he can't get into that team nuff said, really.

[Guest Anders Honoré]

I dunno bout this one. Loaning a player is common nowadays but it also smells like a "you're not gonna be good enough" type thing.

 

Gerrard, Owen, Carragher, Fowler never went on loan.

 

yet..

 

Warnock, Potter, Mellor, etc did

 

Can anyone name a player we've sent out on loan to return as a regular first teamer? Perhaps in the 80s or 90s?

 

warnock is a good example of why you should go on loan as he has come back and been given a chance to stake a claim for a firstteam place.

[floyd]

I dunno bout this one. Loaning a player is common nowadays but it also smells like a "you're not gonna be good enough" type thing.

 

Gerrard, Owen, Carragher, Fowler never went on loan.

 

yet..

 

Warnock, Potter, Mellor, etc did

 

Can anyone name a player we've sent out on loan to return as a regular first teamer? Perhaps in the 80s or 90s?

Can't really a Liverpool player, but others have gone & come back to do better things, Murphy is debateable (except at Castle Greyskull)

 

FV - Preston

Defoe - Bournmouth

Carrick - Swindon

[Boca]

Can't really a Liverpool player, but others have gone & come back to do better things, Murphy is debateable (except at Castle Greyskull)

 

Why is Murphy debatable? You asked can anyone name a player we've sent out on loan to return as a regular first teamer?

 

Murphy did that.

[Bald Devil]

Djimi went on loan to Lens for a season

[IgPig]

I dunno bout this one. Loaning a player is common nowadays but it also smells like a "you're not gonna be good enough" type thing.

 

Gerrard, Owen, Carragher, Fowler never went on loan.

 

yet..

 

Warnock, Potter, Mellor, etc did

 

Can anyone name a player we've sent out on loan to return as a regular first teamer? Perhaps in the 80s or 90s?

 

Staunton went to Bradford on loan.

[Rich Gobey]

Beckham went to Preston, Defoe to Bournmouth.

 

Cant think of any others.

[Guest ritchie_50]

Beckham went to Preston, Defoe to Bournmouth.

 

Cant think of any others.

 

Lampard and Ferdinand at West Ham went on loan at Swansea and Bournemouth.

Edited January 18, 2007 by ritchie_50

[RedLars]

I dunno bout this one. Loaning a player is common nowadays but it also smells like a "you're not gonna be good enough" type thing.

 

Gerrard, Owen, Carragher, Fowler never went on loan.

 

yet..

 

Warnock, Potter, Mellor, etc did

 

Can anyone name a player we've sent out on loan to return as a regular first teamer? Perhaps in the 80s or 90s?

 

I might be wrong but didnt Warnock, Potter and Mellor go on loan while in their early 20's after a few years in the reserves? Adam is still rather young (18 I believe) and this is a good chance for him to get regular and tougher match. Good move at the right time.

[Sion]

Arsenal send a lot of youngsters on loan and it does them no harm, they seem to come back stronger.

[Leo No.8]

Beckham was loaned out by United to Preston as a youngster.

 

Hammill has the talent - he really needs to stand out at Dunfermilne if he's going to make it here though.