Answer needed to quiz question posted on here

[Woodsyla]

How many players who played with Liverpool have won the European Cup with other clubs but not with Liverpool ? I thought it was 9.

 

I've got

 

Babbel, Riedle, Lloyd, Anelka, Litmanen, Macca, Nando

 

so far

[Fenderbaum]

Does Busby count as a manager?

[fred]

Does Matt Busby count?

[Rushian]

Babbel hasn't. Bayern won it the year after he joined us (the same season we won the UEFA Cup).

[Woodsyla]

Does Matt Busby count?

 

Yes

 

Babbel hasn't. Bayern won it the year after he joined us (the same season we won the UEFA Cup).

 

Bugger, he gives and he takes away

 

So that's still 7

[Rich Gobey]

Did Keegan win it with Hamburg in 1983?

 

Did Toshack ever win it as Real Madrid manager?

[Torby]

Sure it is not 9 who has played in a final?

[Cobs]

Did Keegan win it with Hamburg in 1983?

 

nah he was back in Blighty by then

[12twelve]

Owen. He left us to win things.

[Buzz]

Did Robinson win it when he was in Spain?.

[_00_deathscar]

Owen. He left us to win things.

 

:lol:

[Cobs]

Did Robinson win it when he was in Spain?.

Well, he played in the 84 Euro Final for us, which discounts him from the question asked and he only played for Osasuna (i think) in Spain, not sure he won anything there, certainly not the European Cup

[Flasher]

Need to consider the victories by Villa, Forest and Celtic.

 

No names spring to mind yet though.

[Fenderbaum]

Need to consider the victories by Villa, Forest and Celtic.

 

No names spring to mind yet though.

 

Was Walters at Villa?

 

Was Withe ever on our books?

[Spike]

Toshack as Real Madrid manager?

 

 

 

Pellegrino has played in CL finals for Valencia

 

Ziege?

[Woodsyla]

Sure it is not 9 who has played in a final?

 

That may have been it, that gives us Pellegrino for a start.

[Rich Gobey]

Toshack managed Real in1990 and 1999, though Del Bosque was the manager when they won the EC against Valencia.

[dorgie]

Did Keegan win it with Hamburg in 1983?

 

 

No, but I think he played on the Hamburg losing side to Forest

[Cobs]

No, but I think he played on the Hamburg losing side to Forest

aye, he did.

[Guest HarrowRed]

Pellegrini never won it with Valencia

[dorgie]

Babbel hasn't. Bayern won it the year after he joined us (the same season we won the UEFA Cup).

 

Babbel played on the losing Bayern side in 1999.........can't remember who beat them though

[Torby]

Babbel, Riedle, Lloyd, Anelka, Litmanen, Macca, Nando, Keegan and Pellegrino - 9 who played in a final.

[scoose]

keegan never won it for hamburg he was a runner up

[passater]

Did Berger not win it with Dortmund?

[Tosh]

Diomede.

 

Oh no, that was a different medal