Who is more important; Rafa or Steven Gerrard?

[madaboutlfc]

Brain. People can have heart transplants.

should have answered your question

[Nathan Explosion]

Edited to add a poll to make it more juicy.

[Guest bluehouse]

Which leg do you want to lose, left or right?

If I had to loose one it would be left, as I am right footed.

 

Edited to add a poll to make it more juicy.

Thanks I had no idea how to do that.

[Fagan]

without rafa we wouldnt have gerrard, so clearly rafa is more important, cause without gerrard we;d still have rafa.

 

but on a clearer point, rafa is clearly more important. he decides how we play and he gets the best out of stevie. without rafa, we might have a manager who plays a rubbish system and does not harness stevies talents in the proper manner and therefore the effect of steven gerrard is nullified

 

ergo........

 

Rafa rafa benitez, rafa rafa benitez,

more important than gerrard

alonso or tores...(who knows)

[madaboutlfc]

who voted gerrard

[Guz]

whats more important your brain or your heart

 

The heart can beat on its own, cut off the blood supply to the brain and you're dead

[Rimbeux]

without Steven Gerrard we would not have won the european cup and the FA Cup. just to be different

 

 

Aye, and sans the boss we'd not have got into the last 8

[fyds]

Rafa - our greatest signing since King Kenny.

[Guest bluehouse]

This is a topic from that other site.

Its intresting the vast difference in gap between the sites. The other has it much closer. |To me that speaks volumes for members on either site.

[Gomez]

The manager is always more important, be it Rafa or Evans.

 

The manager builds a team, Gerrard is just one player, albeit a very good one.

 

If the manager is crap, it doesn't matter how many Steven Gerrards you have, you'll win jack.

[Benitez]

can't believe anyone voted for a player being more important to this club than the boss

 

Now if Gerrard was unfortunate enough to play for Everton or any other mid table and below crud, then fairynuff, maybe there would be a point to this poll. But then if they where mid table crud - that'd just prove that one player can't do it all

Edited May 26, 2006 by Benitez

[psl]

Just to play devil's advocate, if you asked every top club across Europe whether they'd rather have Rafa or Stevie, I reckon more would say Stevie.

[Benitez]

Just to play devil's advocate, if you asked every top club across Europe whether they'd rather have Rafa or Stevie, I reckon more would say Stevie.

 

 

Top clubs like Milan, Juve, Barca - they have good managers, so of course they'd love another top player. You can have more than one of them! Be like asking us if we'd prefer Etoo or Spitter Riijkaard. We'd say Etoo. But teams without great managers would probably go for Riikjaard.

 

Ask Real Madrid who they'd prefer.

[Case]

What would I prefer..

 

To be reading this inane thread or wiring myself up to the mains.

[mrjunk]

As Captain stevie play a very important role, i'm glad we have both!

[jimmylibel]

without rafa we wouldnt have gerrard,

 

Or Xabi, or Momo, or Reina etc...

[Benitez]

the idiots who voted for one player being more important to the club than the manager, need to have a fecin word with themselves.

 

without Steven Gerrard we would not have won the european cup and the FA Cup. just to be different

 

 

and without Luis Garcia we wouldn't have been in either final, so therefore Luis Garcia is clearly more important than both of them, end of argument

[_00_deathscar]

And without Everton's bustup with Anfield in 1892....

 

Therefore