Jump to content
I will no longer be developing resources for Invision Community Suite ×
By fans, for fans. By fans, for fans. By fans, for fans.

Kvarme Ate My Food

Sponsors
  • Posts

    27,362
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Kvarme Ate My Food

  1. I don’t object at all to a chewing the fat convo. Is it hypothetically possible that we’d be better off now if Tsimikas had come on for 20 mins here and there? Maybe. I’ve no idea. It’s all harmless, of course. But it’s daft.
  2. I did like your answer. I asked why you thought Slot should trust the squad players more, and you said “Based on me watching those players”. That’s a lovely answer. I don’t think it’s at all disingenuous to suggest you were saying you’d seen something that Slot hadn’t.
  3. “We’ll probably never know” is fine. I started all this by responding to “it’s pretty clear” and “the squad players are perfectly capable”.
  4. No that’s not it at all. It’s just a simple question: why has he not used the squad players more? It can only be because he’s calculated that they’re not good enough. Or that he didn’t realise the players he has used would get tired. All managers make mistakes. Of course they do. But this wouldn’t be a one-off mistake. This would be a season-long failure to see what Gethin and Cobs could clearly see. Does that sound likely?
  5. My criticism of someone like Southgate would be that he’s not as good as the managers he’s up against. It wouldn’t be “me and these knobs on a forum can see this very obvious thing that he can’t see”. And you can multiply that by a hundred when it’s someone who’s about to bring us the league title. Yeah, like I said, it’s you thinking you know more about the players and the game than he does. Which, maybe, is the point of a forum but it’s daft isn’t it.
  6. Based on… you knowing the players or the game better than he does? Like I know you were being sarcastic about that but it’s the clear implication of your point. But … I’ve been around football forums long enough to know the next reply is “oh so aren’t we allowed to ever disagree with a manager about anything?” and you’ve been around long enough to know what follows that so let’s not bother.
  7. Why’s he done it then? Because he couldn’t spot the risk that you and Gethin could? Seriously, what’s your hypothesis?
  8. As to why I think he hasn’t used the squad more: I assume it’s because he sees them in training and calculates that he’ll win more games using the players he uses than those he doesn’t.
  9. You haven’t answered the question at all. I didn’t mean my question snidely but I’ll give you snide if you want it.
  10. Serious question: why do you think Slot hasn’t done what you wanted him to do? Do you think it’s because you know the players or understand football better than he does?
  11. I think this is the sort of point to which you’d typically respond “auntie/c**k/uncle”
  12. Ok, I’m not sure of the difference between unexpected success and over performance but I’ll take it in good faith that a distinction exists. For next season, either we continue with several players that Slot doesn’t rate, or we replace several players. Either scenario makes it difficult to win the league.
  13. I think the main thing is we have a new manager who doesn’t have the squad he wants. Brilliant over performance this year — if we’d made signings last summer, finished fourth this year, and won it next then we’d be happy with that. The order of things may have changed a bit. No excuses not to be up there in 26/27 though.
  14. Usually yes, but this is an unusual situation.
  15. I don’t mind if next season is a transition one, and we only get top 4. But I’d want to be winning the title again the year after.
  16. This content is not viewable to guests.,This content is not viewable to guests.
  17. This content is not viewable to guests.,This content is not viewable to guests.
  18. This content is not viewable to guests.,This content is not viewable to guests.
  19. Commolli vibes off this Hughes lad. ”Oh I knew about Virgil dead ages ago.”
  20. Ignore Stanley, he’s gutted I came back. He felt like king of the clique in my absence.
  21. It was me who said that! So yeah I agree.
  22. This thing of, “it isn’t Slot’s squad”. Under the current structure it won’t ever be *his* squad, will it? He’s not in charge of comings and goings.
  23. By God, how does he do it?
  24. Let’s get De Bruyne for a year
×
×
  • Create New...