Hear hear. There's far too much judging of players going on from e-season highlights. When you go to the matches (at any level) you get an appreciation of the level of opposition, how well teammates are linking up, the level of domination of the side. Its the only way you can really tell if a player has outperformed that level and might be ready for a step up. Even then there are other factors like who is ahead of him in the squad. We've just sent Pongolle on loan because he can't break into the 1st team. Now Sinama, at reserve level, looks frighteningly good. Not just head and shoulders above any of our new teenage recruits but on another planet. By comparison, some of the others look just what they are, promising youngsters. I wish more people could go and watch a few reserve games, it really would be an eye opener for the difference in the level of football.