Just looking at it from the club’s point of view, would they want to give 4 year contracts on massive wages to two players who are going the wrong side of 30 in a team whose playing style is so demanding? If we do lose one or both of Salah and Mane I reckon it’s because the club wants it rather than the players want it. If we really wanted them to stay we could make it happen with resigning bonuses etc so as not to affect the wage structure.
Also it would be much easier to attract new, young forwards if there are places up for grabs rather than trying to force their way past those two. I am not having a go at either; they have been brilliant for us and owe us nothing. Likewise we owe them nothing and the club will be looking to move forward for the next few seasons rather than for one year.