See this is too simplistic a way of looking at it to my mind. Our defenders aren't all crap, it's the way the team as a whole is set up to play. We've had a midfield that teams have carved through in the last couple of years, leaving the defence exposed. The flipside when we finished 2nd is that we were scoring for fun so it masked it a little. Last year we didn't even have that. With a team properly set up to defend as a unit, our individual defenders are good enough or certainly not as bad as being made out. This is Rodgers biggest challenge for next season.